Latest posts on Christian Aid

Why 'Christian Hate?'? An introduction to the blog

Places Christians shouldn't go A quick tour of Christian Hate?'s case against Christian Aid

Christians and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict Read all my posts on this topic

Tuesday, July 12, 2005

New Statesman award endorses Christian Aid bias

Early in 2002 the London New Statesman, an influential left-of-centre weekly, printed a cover which attracted such a storm of protest over its implicit anti-Semitism that the editor was forced to issue an apology. However he stood by an article in the same issue dealing with an alleged “Zionist media lobby” in Britain – and in so doing earned himself a pat on the back from the infamous Holocaust denier David Irving (I’m not going to link to his site, but a Google search on “new statesman anti-semitic” will bring it up as the first result).

So when the New Statesman has some gongs to hand out, you’d hope it might be a little careful about choosing the recipients. Not so, unfortunately.

Last night the NS held its New Media Awards bash. The Advocacy award went to the Pressureworks website. Here’s the citation:-

Pressureworks, produced by Christian Aid, describes itself as "a website for a TV/consumer generation that's tired of being lied to". It aims to use "the tools of popular culture . . . to wake the world up". The site provides tools and tips on how to campaign for peace, economic justice, the root causes of poverty and basic rights for all. This is the ideal starting point for anyone wanting to make a difference, whether in the G8 summit protests, the Make Poverty History campaign, or more generally. Stylish, powerful and informative, it embraces new media - and the unique potential it offers - to bring its messages to a wider audience.

The tub-thumping populism of the stuff about the “generation that’s tired of being lied to” should put us on our guard straight away. Pressureworks knows exactly what the world’s problems are, and who is to blame for each of them. Here’s how it goes:

Problem: Third World debt. To blame: The West
Problem: unfair trade. To blame: The West
Problem: HIV/AIDS. To blame: The West
Problem: arms sales. To blame: The West
Problem: Palestinian poverty. To blame: Israel

Yes, that’s all there is to speak of. A search for “Mugabe” throws up no results at all. “Sudan” produces six hits, from which we learn that it’s one of the countries where HIV has been exacerbated by conflict; that there is a lot of oil, and greedy oil companies are to blame for most of the country’s problems; and that people are suffering because the government has to pay so much interest on its debts. Might the Sudanese government’s debts have anything to do with its conducting a genocidal civil war over two decades? That’s just being picky, and it’s all the oil companies’ fault anyway, plus our fault for selling them arms (OK, actually it’s the Chinese who sell them arms, but that’s being really, really picky).

“Palestine” produces 354 hits, and of course it’s the usual story. The Palestinians are poor because of the Occupation, and therefore it’s all Israel’s fault. They have got much poorer since the start of the second Intifada, and that’s still all Israel’s fault – nothing to do with militant/terrorist groups starting a campaign of murder and forcing Israel to step up its security.

A timeline of the conflict is a bit more subtle in its bias than most Christian Aid material. 1948 and 1967 are the litmus tests for evaluating this kind of production. It does concede that in 1948 the Arab states invaded Israel in an attempt to crush it. But to admit that they had exactly the same intention in 1967 would evidently be going too far. So we get the bland statement that “The Six Day War was the inevitable conclusion of years of tension between Israel and its Arab neighbours”.

The site advertises Christian Aid’s Retreat Conference later this month, at which they are “pleased to offer you the chance to learn and pray about Israel and The Occupied Palestinian Territories. No, I’m not joking, the anti-Israel propaganda doesn’t let up even when you go on retreat. When’s the Democratic Republic of the Congo retreat? Be serious.

So that is how Christian Aid seeks to win young hearts and minds with the money it raises from ordinary Christians. All in all, a superb choice for people who might fear that the media are controlled by a shadowy Zionist lobby. Whatever interest it’s serving, it certainly isn’t the truth. It’s time Christian Aid faced some pressure themselves.

3 comments:

N. Friedman said...

You have written another excellent and informative article. Thank you Cyrus.

Anonymous said...

I have only recently discovered this website and wish to encourage you in the good work of presenting reality. There is a verse in Psalm 74 which says that the Lord has mixed a cup of foaming wine and that certain people have drunk it to the dregs. It is pretty obvious that the kinds of things you are making a stand against are perpetrated by those who have been swallowing the stuff which has prevented them from seeing things as they really are. There is one set of standards applied to Israel and a totally different set to the rest of the world, and there is a refusal to even acknowledge that this is so.You are certainly watching from the heights. Thank you. A Christian well-wisher.

Anonymous said...

I too have only just discovered this site and want to thank you for pointing out prejudiced reporting.

Another Christian well-wisher,

ATC, Bristol.